R has lost 4 already and i havent been giving money - she totally isnt interested in money.  for the first tooth she got a hello kitty headband (which i think was about $3.99 at claires), the 2nd she got hello kitty silly bands (however much those cost - like $2?) - for the third she got a mini ugly doll (for $5) and the fourth she got a hello kitty wallet for her lunch money (she buys lunch on fridays) - i think that was $4.99.

I think for now i'll keep going like this and just never exceed $5 per tooth- she's losing them gradually and gets SO excited - i did tell her that sometimes the tooth fairy will bring a dollar instead of a present especially now that the first 4 are gone, but we'll see what kind of mood i'm in when the next one comes out.