Members Login
Username 
 
Password 
    Remember Me  
Post Info TOPIC: Church Research


Guru

Status: Offline
Posts: 10425
Date: Jan 24, 2012
Church Research
Permalink  
 


I'm doing a little church research (and I'm amused that that phrase rhymes).

I was at Bible study this evening, and our leader mentioned that our church has created a new "task force" to work on ways to ignite more of a spark in our church. He said the focus is to get the people who are already there to be more actively involved (although that's not exactly how he said it and not EXACTLY what I mean but close enough) in order for people to see and want to be a part of our church.

I know that several people have left our church for other churches, most recently my brother and sil. And my brother grew up in this church just like i did.

So here's the research part:

If you attend church or tried it, especially if you left one church for another, what was missing from the church(es) you left? And what made you want to be at the church you chose instead?

If you tried church and just stopped going altogether, what was missing that made you leave?

 



__________________

Robin, mom to Henry and Mark

 



Guru

Status: Offline
Posts: 5514
Date: Jan 24, 2012
Permalink  
 

To be honest. I hate the pressure from the church to always feel like I have to do something. I realize it takes volunteers and such to run thing. However, I also feel that church puts a wedge between the little family time I get. At this point in my life I have to say no to things. My kids and myself need down time. I work m-f and get home at 4:30.with only having two days a week to fit all my cleaning, laundry and try to spend quality time with my kids. Maybe later in my life when I am at a different eggs I will be more active in church and other things. Right now my family and raising my children come before all. I feel like church kind of does. It respect the family and how busy life is now. Everyone is at different stages in life. Not everyone can devote the amount of time that others can.


__________________


Guru

Status: Offline
Posts: 5514
Date: Jan 24, 2012
Permalink  
 

OoPs, the reason I liked our church was a good diversity of ages. A good children's program.

__________________


Guru

Status: Offline
Posts: 5514
Date: Jan 24, 2012
Permalink  
 

Can you even make sense of what I wrote? I cannot, lol. Where eggs came from?

__________________


Guru

Status: Offline
Posts: 4910
Date: Jan 24, 2012
Permalink  
 

oh, one more thing.  We are incredibly liberal in our beliefs, but I recall one sermon around Christmas about the ministers beliefs in what was story and what was real (and it was far too removed from the Christmas story even for us...imagine a history professor who is also your theologian- sometimes the mix just doesn't blend well.  She is a VERY educated woman which works well in this university townh...but it was too much).  It just didn't settle right with Travis even more than me- and I would classify him as barely willing to go to church to begin with.  Everything else had been bothering us, the direction of the sermons caused us to close the door on that church.

Of course everyone in town goes to that church so it is super awkward when we run into people and are invited back again and again.  In that case, I'm sort of glad we are moving.  We still get postcards and letters from them inviting us back all the time.



-- Edited by supergrover on Tuesday 24th of January 2012 06:56:14 AM

__________________







Guru

Status: Offline
Posts: 7897
Date: Jan 24, 2012
Permalink  
 

hahahahaha. nothing makes my day better than reading melissa posting from an ipad.

robin, i just started attending a church. if you want, i can tell you what helped me decide it was a good fit for me/us.

__________________


Guru

Status: Offline
Posts: 7138
Date: Jan 24, 2012
Permalink  
 

I've never "not" been in church, but I've changed churches and denominations throughout my life.

Growing up, I changed of course, when my parents changed.  We switched from Presbyterian to Baptist, mainly because of the preacher.  The Presbyterian lost a pastor and it took them FOREVER to find another one, so we started attending the Baptist church just because it was steady.  We stayed there because we really loved the preacher and the people.

When I got married and Kenneth and I joined a church, we switched once we had kids.  The one we were attending was a teeny, tiny country church, with nothing really to do for the kids.  We joined Pisgah, which I love and miss to this day.

Then, when we moved here, we visited a couple of different ones, trying to find our place.

What made us choose First Baptist, was first the preacher.  He preaches strictly from the bible, which is what I believe they're supposed to do, preach from God's word.  Then was the friendliness of the people.    It just felt right.  It took us a while to join, several months, but when we did, we've been happy ever since.  We've had to change SS classes, but still really love the church. 

I didn't fully understand the importance of tithing and the importance of putting God before everything else in my life until the last 10 years or so.  (even though I grew up in church)  Before that, before I fully got the gist of what all that meant, if I'd heard that all the time, it would've driven me away. 

That being said, I don't think churches should leave any of that out of their sermons, it's in the bible, therefore it's important, but for "new" Christians, they need more than that.

Does that make sense?



-- Edited by Juanita on Tuesday 24th of January 2012 08:16:19 AM

__________________


Guru

Status: Offline
Posts: 7138
Date: Jan 24, 2012
Permalink  
 

CoffeeQueen wrote:

Jen - question. When you say putting God before everything else. To what extent and who determines this? I always get hung up on this honestly. I feel like I can have a relationship with God and put him first, but to me, that does not mean also at the cost of raising my children. Does God want me to not see my kids? I personally would not think so. So, if someone belongs to a church, but cannot be as active as a member as some of the others. Is that person not putting God first? I feel like that is where it all gets a bit icky for me if you will.

I feel like what is preached and what is needed do not always match. Most of the church stuff if you will are man made activities, etc. So, to me that is not really what it is all about. One can give and be active in many areas of their life and not in the church per say. What are your thoughts on this?


 For me, (and this is just what I've learned for me), it's not about being as active in the church as others.    That's not what putting God first means to me.  It means putting my time with God above everything else.  For example, the very first thing I do in the morning is get in his word and pray.  I have my time with him first, then I deal with my kids, husband and whatever else.  It just makes my day go smoother.  What I do in the church has not a single thing to do with my relationship with God (in my opinion).  I don't do a lot in the church, we work in the nursery, Kenneth helped in VBS this summer, but that's not near as much as what others do..however, I believe it's all we're called to do right now.  God knows our hearts, he knows what we can or can't do and he makes a way for all of that. 

So, I 100% agree with you..you can give and be active in many ways, and not take away from your kids.  That is definitely what the Lord wants you to do smile

Did that make sense?  I'm in total agreement with what you said about your involvement in church.



-- Edited by Juanita on Tuesday 24th of January 2012 08:48:27 AM

__________________


Guru

Status: Offline
Posts: 7138
Date: Jan 24, 2012
Permalink  
 

kris wrote:

First I will answer Robin's question - this will probably be long and more than you want to know wink

I did not grow up in a church.  If I went it was b/c my aunt and uncle picked me up and took me with their family on an occasional Sunday. 

As an adult I started attending a church about 12 years ago.  DS1 was 2 years old.  I had been wanting to go to the church but scared to walk in alone with a 2 year old (DH had no interest in going).   The lady who took care of John invited us to come to VBS and I found out it was the same church I'd been wanting to attend so I decided to go.   They had the closing program on a Friday and invited everyone to church Sunday and I went back.  That is how I started going to this church - so, VBS is a wonderful way of inviting people in and making them feel welcomed and loved!

Eventually my husband did start going with us to church.  We were baptised together a couple years later.  

As far as being active we attended Wednesday night dinners and then church afterwards and liked that.  We volunteered at VBS a couple of times (even teaching kids classes when I really did not feel qualified to do so - maybe it was pressure that led to us committing to do that I don't really remember - I clearly should have been a snack hander outter and not someone trying to teach children about Jesus b/c I didn't even know enough at the time to teach anyone!).

What really did not sit well with my husband was that about once a month the preacher preached about giving and money and how we needed to be giving more financially.   A donation for the building project, a regular donation.  It just was too frequent and really turned my husband off.

Another thing that led to us stopping this church was what felt like gossiping or obvious situations where people were talking about us and our family situation.    A lady from the church approached me at a restaurant, we had never met before - she told me that one of the ladies at the church suggested she talk to me about her son b/c I had a son that was "really hard to control" and perhaps I could give her some tips.  That did not sit well with me . . .  nobody talked to me about my "hard to control" son or offered me any tips or thoughts or even any recognition of our parenting hardships with John yet they knew enough to suggest this lady talk to me or seek me out for advice?

We also hit a particularly rough patch in our marriage and learned that there were lots of discussions going on about our situation that were untrue and hurtful.  This, for me, being a "new" Christian was very hard to swallow.  These people were supposed to be people of God and be better and they used my marital problems as fodder over coffee at their scrapbook parties.  Hurtful and honestly turned me off entirely to church for many years.  We stopped attending this church at that point.

Now . . .having said that last paragraph and being where I am now I realize that being a Christian does not make life easy.  everyone sins and falls short.  what they did was not right but they are human.

soooooooo I'll end this here - this is what got us into church initially and what ended our church going days for many years to come.

sorry its so long.


 I have some thoughts on this paragraph.

I don't know because I wasn't there and I don't know these people's hearts or there intentions, but I know that people used to aggravate the snot out of me by doing this too.  People I didn't know would come over and offer advice, ask for advice or whatever about Presley's condition.  I wondered why these people were talking about our family and sticking their nose in our business. 

Then I realized, maybe they really do care and maybe they really do want to help or get my advice on things.  I tried to let go of the thinking that they were talking about me or whatever, and tried to focus on maybe God laid this on their hearts to come to me.  Maybe those people were sitting around talking and they said "you know, Jennifer Sones is in the same situation you are, maybe you should ask her how she handles it"

Now, I'm not saying this is what you should've done or said, because I don't know the situation, they very well could've been gossiping.  But, I'm hoping they weren't smile

What made you decide to finally become members of the church you're at now?

ETA: As far as the gossip about your marital problems, that was wrong, wrong, wrong.  But, you have to remember, even the devil is at church biggrin



-- Edited by Juanita on Tuesday 24th of January 2012 10:10:27 AM

__________________


Guru

Status: Offline
Posts: 4910
Date: Jan 24, 2012
Permalink  
 

What I liked and why we stayed as long as we did:  Friendly, very inclusive, decent childrens program

Why we left:  The pressure to give more and more money weaved into most sermons got to be too much.  The switch from volunteers to cover things to being automatically written into the schedule and if you couldn't do it, you had to find someone else was also a turn off. 

Why I have a hard time trying new churches:  I prefer to be able to understand it before I go the first time.  I really like churches where I can look at their website and it describes what a typical Sunday is like.  Does EVERYONE go to Sunday school first, or just some?  If you don't go to SUnday school, where should you go vs those that attended.  If you are bringing a child, what are the ages of who goes where?  How often is communion, and in that particular faith, who receives it?  Etc.

Like Melissa, I understand it takes money and volunteers.  However, when you are not already rooted into the church, those things make you run.

All that said, we will be trying a new church.  The ONLY reason at this point?  The childrens program.  Without them, I don't think we'd even try it.



__________________







Guru

Status: Offline
Posts: 10425
Date: Jan 24, 2012
Permalink  
 

apies wrote:

hahahahaha. nothing makes my day better than reading melissa posting from an ipad.

robin, i just started attending a church. if you want, i can tell you what helped me decide it was a good fit for me/us.


 Yes, I would love to hear your thoughts!



__________________

Robin, mom to Henry and Mark

 



Guru

Status: Offline
Posts: 7138
Date: Jan 24, 2012
Permalink  
 

Kris totally needs to be in this conversation, her family just joined a church for the first time.

She'd have some wonderful thoughts smile



__________________


Guru

Status: Offline
Posts: 7138
Date: Jan 24, 2012
Permalink  
 

Robin, I'm curious

What made your brother leave the church he grew up in?



__________________


Guru

Status: Offline
Posts: 5514
Date: Jan 24, 2012
Permalink  
 

Jen - question. When you say putting God before everything else. To what extent and who determines this? I always get hung up on this honestly. I feel like I can have a relationship with God and put him first, but to me, that does not mean also at the cost of raising my children. Does God want me to not see my kids? I personally would not think so. So, if someone belongs to a church, but cannot be as active as a member as some of the others. Is that person not putting God first? I feel like that is where it all gets a bit icky for me if you will.

I feel like what is preached and what is needed do not always match. Most of the church stuff if you will are man made activities, etc. So, to me that is not really what it is all about. One can give and be active in many areas of their life and not in the church per say. What are your thoughts on this?

__________________


Guru

Status: Offline
Posts: 5514
Date: Jan 24, 2012
Permalink  
 

Juanita wrote:
CoffeeQueen wrote:

Jen - question. When you say putting God before everything else. To what extent and who determines this? I always get hung up on this honestly. I feel like I can have a relationship with God and put him first, but to me, that does not mean also at the cost of raising my children. Does God want me to not see my kids? I personally would not think so. So, if someone belongs to a church, but cannot be as active as a member as some of the others. Is that person not putting God first? I feel like that is where it all gets a bit icky for me if you will.

I feel like what is preached and what is needed do not always match. Most of the church stuff if you will are man made activities, etc. So, to me that is not really what it is all about. One can give and be active in many areas of their life and not in the church per say. What are your thoughts on this?


 For me, (and this is just what I've learned for me), it's not about being as active in the church as others.    That's not what putting God first means to me.  It means putting my time with God above everything else.  For example, the very first thing I do in the morning is get in his word and pray.  I have my time with him first, then I deal with my kids, husband and whatever else.  It just makes my day go smoother.  What I do in the church has not a single thing to do with my relationship with God (in my opinion).  I don't do a lot in the church, we work in the nursery, Kenneth helped in VBS this summer, but that's not near as much as what others do..however, I believe it's all we're called to do right now.  God knows our hearts, he knows what we can or can't do and he makes a way for all of that. 

So, I 100% agree with you..you can give and be active in many ways, and not take away from your kids.  That is definitely what the Lord wants you to do smile

Did that make sense?  I'm in total agreement with what you said about your involvement in church.



-- Edited by Juanita on Tuesday 24th of January 2012 08:48:27 AM


 ok, that is what I thought you meant, but was not sure. 

that is the one problem I have with organized religion. It is all the  man made rules and pressure. I feel like I am always being asked to attend, give, help and it is just too much for me at this stage in my life. So, it makes me want to pull back. It is not anything to do with my beliefs or spiritual relationship. However, I think that does turn people off these days. I have heard this from a few friends.



__________________


Guru

Status: Offline
Posts: 2797
Date: Jan 24, 2012
Permalink  
 

Robin, I have switched to different churches for various reasons, but generally it is because I moved. I will say that when looking for a church I have had problems with some of them. I don't like churches that promote the "right" kind of family. In other words if you are not a traditional family in every sense of the word, there is an underlying tone of disapproval. I mostly encountered this as a single parent, but I think it also applies to people in mixed marriages, grandparents raising grandkids, and those of certain social/economic groups along with many others. For me, a good church opens its doors and welcomes all. When you walk in the door you will find people from various walks of life.

I also don't need a guilt trip. If I say I can help by doing xyz, I don't want told it's not good enough. I also think it's good when members have the ability to offer and utilize their talents that are not necessarily ones listed on the forms. While money is important, I think that one's service should not be discounted. I also think that if I am involved and serving in some way for the church I am more likely to donate money.

__________________


Guru

Status: Offline
Posts: 7138
Date: Jan 24, 2012
Permalink  
 

CoffeeQueen wrote:
Juanita wrote:
CoffeeQueen wrote:

Jen - question. When you say putting God before everything else. To what extent and who determines this? I always get hung up on this honestly. I feel like I can have a relationship with God and put him first, but to me, that does not mean also at the cost of raising my children. Does God want me to not see my kids? I personally would not think so. So, if someone belongs to a church, but cannot be as active as a member as some of the others. Is that person not putting God first? I feel like that is where it all gets a bit icky for me if you will.

I feel like what is preached and what is needed do not always match. Most of the church stuff if you will are man made activities, etc. So, to me that is not really what it is all about. One can give and be active in many areas of their life and not in the church per say. What are your thoughts on this?


 For me, (and this is just what I've learned for me), it's not about being as active in the church as others.    That's not what putting God first means to me.  It means putting my time with God above everything else.  For example, the very first thing I do in the morning is get in his word and pray.  I have my time with him first, then I deal with my kids, husband and whatever else.  It just makes my day go smoother.  What I do in the church has not a single thing to do with my relationship with God (in my opinion).  I don't do a lot in the church, we work in the nursery, Kenneth helped in VBS this summer, but that's not near as much as what others do..however, I believe it's all we're called to do right now.  God knows our hearts, he knows what we can or can't do and he makes a way for all of that. 

So, I 100% agree with you..you can give and be active in many ways, and not take away from your kids.  That is definitely what the Lord wants you to do smile

Did that make sense?  I'm in total agreement with what you said about your involvement in church.



-- Edited by Juanita on Tuesday 24th of January 2012 08:48:27 AM


 ok, that is what I thought you meant, but was not sure. 

that is the one problem I have with organized religion. It is all the  man made rules and pressure. I feel like I am always being asked to attend, give, help and it is just too much for me at this stage in my life. So, it makes me want to pull back. It is not anything to do with my beliefs or spiritual relationship. However, I think that does turn people off these days. I have heard this from a few friends.


 I've said this a gazillion times, I could give a rats butt about organized religion..that's NOT what Jesus wants, he wants a relationship with us, so I totally agree with the man made crap.

There are some things they do that's biblical, tithing, praying, reading God's word,  etc...I agree with all that, but as far as the "rules" they make up, ICK on that!

Attendance to me is very important.  I believe God wants us in church, with other believers.  I *need* that refreshment each week.   When I don't go to church, my week isn't nearly as good as when I go and get recharged.   And I'm pretty simple in my thinking.  Jesus felt like it was important to go to temple, so that's good enough for me, lol. 

However, I don't want a church that makes me feel like crap if I don't go to church every Sunday (which I don't sometimes), so don't pressure me and make me feel bad if I miss a Sunday or two.  But on the same token, if I DO miss a few Sundays in a row, I like for someone (and this is where SS class is important for me) to at least check and see if we're okay.



__________________


Guru

Status: Offline
Posts: 7138
Date: Jan 24, 2012
Permalink  
 

happylib wrote:

Robin, I have switched to different churches for various reasons, but generally it is because I moved. I will say that when looking for a church I have had problems with some of them. I don't like churches that promote the "right" kind of family. In other words if you are not a traditional family in every sense of the word, there is an underlying tone of disapproval. I mostly encountered this as a single parent, but I think it also applies to people in mixed marriages, grandparents raising grandkids, and those of certain social/economic groups along with many others. For me, a good church opens its doors and welcomes all. When you walk in the door you will find people from various walks of life.

I also don't need a guilt trip. If I say I can help by doing xyz, I don't want told it's not good enough. I also think it's good when members have the ability to offer and utilize their talents that are not necessarily ones listed on the forms. While money is important, I think that one's service should not be discounted. I also think that if I am involved and serving in some way for the church I am more likely to donate money.


 YES!

I believe the Lord lays on our hearts what we're supposed to do in church and when, I don't need anyone telling me it's not enough.



__________________


Guru

Status: Offline
Posts: 6179
Date: Jan 24, 2012
Permalink  
 

First I will answer Robin's question - this will probably be long and more than you want to know wink

I did not grow up in a church.  If I went it was b/c my aunt and uncle picked me up and took me with their family on an occasional Sunday. 

As an adult I started attending a church about 12 years ago.  DS1 was 2 years old.  I had been wanting to go to the church but scared to walk in alone with a 2 year old (DH had no interest in going).   The lady who took care of John invited us to come to VBS and I found out it was the same church I'd been wanting to attend so I decided to go.   They had the closing program on a Friday and invited everyone to church Sunday and I went back.  That is how I started going to this church - so, VBS is a wonderful way of inviting people in and making them feel welcomed and loved!

Eventually my husband did start going with us to church.  We were baptised together a couple years later.  

As far as being active we attended Wednesday night dinners and then church afterwards and liked that.  We volunteered at VBS a couple of times (even teaching kids classes when I really did not feel qualified to do so - maybe it was pressure that led to us committing to do that I don't really remember - I clearly should have been a snack hander outter and not someone trying to teach children about Jesus b/c I didn't even know enough at the time to teach anyone!).

What really did not sit well with my husband was that about once a month the preacher preached about giving and money and how we needed to be giving more financially.   A donation for the building project, a regular donation.  It just was too frequent and really turned my husband off.

Another thing that led to us stopping this church was what felt like gossiping or obvious situations where people were talking about us and our family situation.    A lady from the church approached me at a restaurant, we had never met before - she told me that one of the ladies at the church suggested she talk to me about her son b/c I had a son that was "really hard to control" and perhaps I could give her some tips.  That did not sit well with me . . .  nobody talked to me about my "hard to control" son or offered me any tips or thoughts or even any recognition of our parenting hardships with John yet they knew enough to suggest this lady talk to me or seek me out for advice?

We also hit a particularly rough patch in our marriage and learned that there were lots of discussions going on about our situation that were untrue and hurtful.  This, for me, being a "new" Christian was very hard to swallow.  These people were supposed to be people of God and be better and they used my marital problems as fodder over coffee at their scrapbook parties.  Hurtful and honestly turned me off entirely to church for many years.  We stopped attending this church at that point.

Now . . .having said that last paragraph and being where I am now I realize that being a Christian does not make life easy.  everyone sins and falls short.  what they did was not right but they are human.

soooooooo I'll end this here - this is what got us into church initially and what ended our church going days for many years to come.

sorry its so long.



__________________


Guru

Status: Offline
Posts: 6179
Date: Jan 24, 2012
Permalink  
 

CoffeeQueen wrote:

Jen - question. When you say putting God before everything else. To what extent and who determines this? I always get hung up on this honestly. I feel like I can have a relationship with God and put him first, but to me, that does not mean also at the cost of raising my children. Does God want me to not see my kids? I personally would not think so. So, if someone belongs to a church, but cannot be as active as a member as some of the others. Is that person not putting God first? I feel like that is where it all gets a bit icky for me if you will.

I feel like what is preached and what is needed do not always match. Most of the church stuff if you will are man made activities, etc. So, to me that is not really what it is all about. One can give and be active in many areas of their life and not in the church per say. What are your thoughts on this?


 re red:  Personally, I do not view "putting God first" as the act of voluteering or going to church even really.   For me the words words putting God first means studying the bible, praying, living a life that would please God.  

re blue:  I think as a congregation we are all in different seasons of our lives.  For me personally, on Sunday mornings, God knows where I'm at and he wants me on my butt in the sanctuary listening to the preacher and learning more and more.    He does not expect me to be teaching in a classroom of children . . .that is not where I am.  Now, when my kids are grown and I'm more mature and versed in my faith I can see myself serving the children.  But right now, I'm thirsty for knowledge and I know where I need to be and I believe that is exactly where God wants me during this season of my life.



__________________
1 2 36  >  Last»  | Page of 6  sorted by
 
Quick Reply

Please log in to post quick replies.

Post to Digg Post to Del.icio.us


Create your own FREE Forum
Report Abuse
Powered by ActiveBoard