I hear duct tape will be all the rage in fall, just saying.
I'm the worse when it comes to shoes. I only own like four pairs, but my thoughts were: would being fitted for arch supports help? Also, for summer, Travis swears by Birkenstocks because I guess they mold to your feet. Though I don't recommend taking Birks into winter like he does and pairing them with white socks.
I have come to the conclusion that unless you have prepregnancy feet, shoe selection is exteremly difficult. Frankly, I have trouble finding anything that fits and wearable beyond the ugly sensible shoes. I also have better luck with slip ons like clogs and sandals than I do with a real shoe. I usually end up with one pair I can wear for the season and then that's all I wear.
I have NO idea what to tell you, Sonya. My feet got bigger (and wider), but I haven't had too much trouble.
That said, I basically live in crocs (not the traditional ones-but the brand-I have all kinds of crocs, lol. I might be single handedly keeping them in business) so I might not be the best one to ask. I also don't have to wear anything nice for work or anything, so that helps.
You know, crocs makes heels too. Seriously. I adore crocs. And they are opening up an entire crocs store at my mall! (they have a kiosk, but it is limited) I am so excited, I can hardly stand it. Yes, I know how sad that is.